Former W.A.S.P. guitarist Chris Holmes has sparked conversation among rock fans by sharing his candid thoughts on two of the most celebrated guitarists of all time—Eddie Van Halen and Randy Rhoads. In a recent discussion, Holmes made it clear that while he deeply respects Rhoads’ talent, he personally considers Van Halen the superior guitarist.
For Holmes, the distinction comes down to style and atmosphere. “Eddie was all about the party,” Holmes said, recalling the wild, high-energy vibe that surrounded Van Halen during their rise. “I liked the Van Halen party better than Quiet Riot’s. It was just more fun, more about letting loose.”
Holmes emphasized that his preference is less about dismissing Rhoads’ technical brilliance and more about aligning with Van Halen’s approach to music and lifestyle. “I don’t hate Randy at all—I respect the hell out of what he did. But when it comes to what I enjoy, I’d take the Van Halen party any day. Drink, play, have fun—that was the vibe.”
Rhoads, known for his neoclassical precision and groundbreaking work with Ozzy Osbourne, brought a meticulous, almost scholarly approach to guitar playing. Van Halen, on the other hand, pioneered a flashier, more spontaneous style built around his revolutionary tapping technique and larger-than-life stage presence.
For Holmes, the choice between the two icons reflects more than guitar notes—it represents a lifestyle. “Randy was incredible, but Eddie’s whole thing was just more appealing to me. He made the guitar exciting, but he also made you want to grab a drink and be part of the party.”
Holmes’ comments highlight a long-standing debate in the rock community: should guitarists be judged purely by their technical skill, or does the atmosphere and attitude they create matter just as much?
One thing is certain—whether through Rhoads’ disciplined mastery or Van Halen’s electrifying showmanship, both guitarists shaped the sound and spirit of rock in ways that continue to inspire musicians today.
